
My last post mentioned children at Mass and provoked this comment from someone called Mercy:
I think it's wrong of you to be so sarcastic about children on the altar. The Alive-O programme encourages the priest to include them in liturgies like Sunday Eucharist and prayer services. How else are children to learn how to ritualise their lives and see the connection between their experience of Christmas and Christian faith?
Pleased to meet you Mrs Red Rag. Your sincerely Mr Bull.
Firstly I wasn't sarcastic. There was no intention to hurt anyone which I think is key ingredient in sarcasm.
Secondly, anything to do with Alive-O is by definition rubbish - from the cheap cartoon drawings to the silly songs and St Gobnait's bees and the missing underlying theology and respect for children. It is cheap, tawdry, 1970s inspired drivel.
Thirdly, children should be included in liturgy by saying their prayers and by being brought to a deeper understanding of what happens during the Mass. As children they can, if old enough, serve Mass and bring up the gifts. They can take up the collection. But always, like all the faithful, their full and active participation comes from their silent joining with the sacrifice of the priest.
Fourthly, I don't want them to ritualise their lives. I don't want them to equate silly little makey uppy rituals involving stones or leaves or standing round a candle with the liturgy - a ritual which God provides, not man.
Fifthly, I don't want to move from their experience of Christmas to Christian faith. This is the classic Alive-O mistake. We have a revealed religion. The Word of God has come down among us. We don't have to keep making it up again and again.